Florida went to Lexington on Saturday and beat Kentucky 21-14. Five days later, the College Football Playoff committee put Kentucky at No. 16 and Florida at No. 24. Eight spots higher for the team that lost the game.
This one wasn’t a fluke either. Kentucky led 14-10 in the third quarter, and Florida answered. Aaron Philo ran it in from 2 yards out with 9:08 left, the Gators hit the two-point try, and Kentucky never scored again. Philo ran for 102 yards. Florida’s defense held the Wildcats to 14 points at home.
Now, the committee will say Kentucky is 7-3 and Florida is 6-4. Fine. One more win. So let’s look at who those wins came against.
- Florida’s best wins: at Texas (No. 5 in the CFP rankings), at Kentucky (No. 16), and Ole Miss (No. 25).
- Kentucky’s best wins: at South Carolina (No. 21) and at Oklahoma (No. 22).
- Losses: Kentucky lost to Alabama, Tennessee and Florida. Florida lost to Missouri, South Carolina, Georgia and Oklahoma.
Florida has the best win of either team by a mile, a road win over a top-five team, and it has the head-to-head. That’s our rule, and it should be the committee’s: when two teams are close, the one who won the game goes ahead. Kentucky played a nice season. It just doesn’t get to lose at home and move up anyway.
Same committee, same week, that has Alabama six spots ahead of a Tennessee team that beat them by 16. We already asked to see those ballots. Add this one to the pile.
Faders, settle it on X @fiveandafade or Instagram. Scores, records and rankings from ESPN.
Every pick is free. Get them by email: subscribe here.
Jeremy Durham is a sports columnist for TriStar Daily and the founder of Five and a Fade.

