Tennessee and Alabama are both 8-2. Tennessee beat Alabama 26-10 on Oct. 17. And the College Football Playoff committee has Alabama No. 3 and Tennessee No. 9. Six spots.
I’ve made my peace with the committee disagreeing with me. What I can’t make peace with is that we’ll never know who disagreed, or why.
The AP shows its work. The committee doesn’t.
Every AP Top 25 voter’s ballot is made public. If a writer has your team too low, you can look it up, find his name and tell him about it. That’s accountability. This week’s AP poll, for the record, has Alabama seventh and Tennessee ninth. Still wrong on head-to-head, but two spots, not six.
The committee works the other way. Its own published voting process runs seven rounds of listing and ranking teams, and the last line says it plainly: all votes are by secret ballot. Then one person, the chair, walks out and explains a room full of votes on TV. Right now that’s Hunter Yurachek, and he’s taking every bit of the heat.
Too much data, not enough football
When the committee had Alabama ahead of Tennessee on Nov. 10, Yurachek said Alabama was No. 1 in record strength and No. 1 in schedule strength, and that Alabama was in the committee’s “first pool” of teams while Tennessee wasn’t (Bleacher Report has the full quote). That’s the problem in one sentence. Give smart people a pile of metrics and they’ll find a way to rank the team that lost by 16 ahead of the team that won by 16.
My fix is simple. Less data, and show us the ballots. If you’re confident Alabama is the third-best team in America, put your name on it.
Tennessee can’t vote. Tennessee can only win. LSU comes to Neyland on Saturday. Let’s go.
Agree? Tell us on X @fiveandafade or on Instagram.
Every pick is free. Get them by email: subscribe here.
Jeremy Durham is a sports columnist for TriStar Daily and the founder of Five and a Fade.

