ESPN’s College GameDay spent Saturday morning in Coral Gables, with Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson as the guest picker for Miami vs. Virginia Tech. Good show. Wrong town. The best story in college football today kicks off at 2:30 p.m. Central in Knoxville.
Let me make Miami’s case first, because it’s a real one. The Hurricanes are 9-1 and 7-0 in the ACC, and they can clinch a spot in the ACC Championship Game tonight against Virginia Tech, which is 6-4 in James Franklin’s first season. The Rock is a Miami legend. And it’s a thin week: the USA TODAY Network noted it’s the first week since 2009 without a game between two AP Top 25 teams.
But GameDay is supposed to go where the story is, and the story is Lane Kiffin walking back into Neyland Stadium.
- Kiffin coached the Vols for one season, 2009, and left for USC that January.
- His last trip to Knoxville, with Ole Miss in 2021, ended with stuff raining onto the field.
- Now he brings LSU (6-4) to No. 9 Tennessee (8-2) on ABC, with the Vols getting points at home.
You can’t script that. A coach, a fan base that has never let it go, 100,000 people and a home underdog with a Playoff case. That’s a three-hour pregame show that writes itself.
To be fair to ESPN, GameDay already came to Knoxville in Week 4 for Texas, so maybe they figured they’d been. Fine. Then Neyland gets to make the point the old-fashioned way: loudest crowd of the year, nothing on the field, and a Tennessee win that has the whole country talking about the Vols tonight instead of the guest picker.
I already gave my call in the Short below: Vegas loves LSU a lot more than LSU loves Vegas. The Vols +1.5 is this week’s Hat Guarantee.
So, Faders: did GameDay get it right, or should the buses be parked on Volunteer Boulevard? Tell me on X @fiveandafade or on Instagram. Records, kickoff times and TV from ESPN.
Every pick is free. Get them by email: subscribe here.
Jeremy Durham is a sports columnist for TriStar Daily and the founder of Five and a Fade.

