Butch Jones Is Out at Arkansas State, and Vols Fans Owe Him More Credit Than He Ever Got

Five and a Fade card: Butch Jones is out at Arkansas State. Vols fans owe the former Tennessee coach more credit.

Watch Jeremy on YouTube and follow on Facebook:

Arkansas State has told Butch Jones he’s out at the end of the season, ESPN’s Pete Thamel reported Monday night. The Red Wolves are 4-6 after a 28-21 loss to Coastal Carolina, and the school still has to decide whether Jones coaches the last two games against Louisiana Tech and Troy.

Here’s the part every Tennessee fan noticed: 4-6. That’s the exact record Tennessee was sitting on when it fired Butch Jones on November 12, 2017, the day after a 50-17 loss at Missouri. His last Vols team never got to play its next game. That next game was LSU.

And who does Tennessee play Saturday? LSU. College football writes the best scripts.

Give the man his due

It ended badly in Knoxville. Nobody’s pretending it didn’t. But a lot of Vols fans remember only the last 10 games and forget what came before them, and that’s not fair.

  • Three straight bowl wins. The TaxSlayer after the 2014 season was Tennessee’s first bowl win since 2007. Then the Outback and the Music City.
  • Back-to-back 9-4 seasons in 2015 and 2016.
  • The streak. In 2016, Tennessee beat Florida 38-28 and snapped the Gators’ 11-game winning streak in the series.
  • The Hail Mary. One week later, Josh Dobbs beat Georgia on the last play of the game.

He went 34-27 at Tennessee. That’s not a championship coach. But he took over a program that hadn’t won a bowl game in seven years and handed his successor one that expected to win them. Somebody had to do the unglamorous rebuild, and he did it.

He did a version of it again in Jonesboro, too. His first Arkansas State team went 2-10. Three years later they were in a bowl game, and they went to three straight, which earned him an extension through 2029 in December 2024. He finishes 30-43 there.

Our take

Butch Jones was never going to be the guy who won Tennessee an SEC title. But he was the guy who got the Vols off the mat, and the team that walks into Neyland Saturday at 8-2 is standing on a floor he helped lay. If you’re a Vols fan, you’re allowed to laugh at the 4-6 coincidence. Just tip your cap while you do it.

He’ll coach again somewhere. Guys who can rebuild a program from 2-10 always do.

Where do you rank the Butch years in Vols history? Tell us on X @fiveandafade or on Instagram.

Every pick is free. Get them by email: subscribe here.

Jeremy Durham is a sports columnist for TriStar Daily and the founder of Five and a Fade.

Don’t miss the next take

New Vols and college football takes every day. Pick your spot and follow.

Want more Five and a Fade when you search Google? Tap below and check the box. Takes 10 seconds.

Get Five and a Fade every Friday

The Vols pick, the college card, the fade and the record, in your inbox once a week. Free.