Oklahoma is 6-4 and not in the new AP Top 25. Florida is 6-4 and ranked No. 23. Ole Miss is 6-4 and ranked No. 25. Oklahoma beat both of them, and not in a coin-flip way.
The Sooners went to Gainesville on Nov. 8 and won 23-7. Then they held off Ole Miss 24-17 in Norman on Sunday. Same record, two head-to-head wins, and the AP voters still put the Gators and the Rebels in and left OU out.
It wasn’t even close to a mystery who was next in line. Oklahoma got 95 points, the most of any unranked team, just 8 behind Ole Miss at No. 25 (103).
My take
When the records are the same, the head-to-head should settle it. That’s not complicated. If you beat a team on its own field by 16, you don’t get to sit behind it a week later.
Here’s the fair case against the Sooners: they lost at home to Kentucky and got run 42-25 by South Carolina in Norman. Those are real losses, and I get why a voter hesitates. But Florida and Ole Miss have four losses too, and one of those losses for each of them came against Oklahoma. You can’t use the losses to keep OU out and ignore the wins over the two teams you just ranked.
Oklahoma also has a 27-24 win over Texas, which is No. 8 in this same poll. That’s the best win of the three teams by a mile.
OU gets Texas A&M in Norman on Saturday. Win that and nobody can keep this up.
Should Oklahoma be ranked over Florida and Ole Miss? Tell me on X @fiveandafade or on Instagram. Rankings and scores from ESPN.
Every pick is free. Get them by email: subscribe here.
Jeremy Durham is a sports columnist for TriStar Daily and the founder of Five and a Fade.

