Titans Now Have Four First-Round Picks in Two Drafts. History Says Fans Are Right to Worry

Typical Titans? Four firsts, no more excuses: Jeremy Durham on the Titans after the Jeffery Simmons trade

Titans fans have one word for the Jeffery Simmons trade, and it isn’t “rebuild.” It’s “typical.”

Tennessee sent Simmons and a 2028 fifth-round pick to Chicago for the Bears’ 2027 first-round pick, their 2028 first-round pick and a 2027 fourth-rounder. Add the Titans’ own picks and they now hold two first-rounders in 2027 and two more in 2028. At 1-6, their own 2027 pick sits near the top of the draft order right now.

That’s a lot of ammunition. The problem is what fans keep saying in every reply: the picks don’t matter if you can’t draft.

They have receipts. The last time Tennessee traded a star for a first-round pick, it sent A.J. Brown to Philadelphia and used the No. 18 pick on Treylon Burks. Before that, Isaiah Wilson and Caleb Farley were both first-round picks that didn’t pan out in Nashville.

Here’s the deal: four first-rounders in two drafts, a new dome opening in 2027 and a different front office than the one that made those picks. No more excuses. Hit on these, or this trade was a going-out-of-business sale.

Also this week: my Vols column, Tennessee Had the Experts Beat. Then It Beat Itself.

More takes every day on X and Instagram at @fiveandafade.

Every pick is free. Get them by email: subscribe here.

Jeremy Durham is a sports columnist for TriStar Daily and the founder of Five and a Fade.

Get Five and a Fade every Friday

The Vols pick, the college and NFL cards, the fade and the record, in your inbox once a week. Free.